9 Comments
User's avatar
Jamie's avatar

just requested That book is dangerous from my library, thanks! also i’ve been reading Attack from Within by barbara mcquade, which i believe you had recommended in a past letter, it’s great and so poignant in these insane times!

Expand full comment
Jan Harayda's avatar

Thanks a million for letting me know, Jamie. I wrote about a talk McQuade gave here that really struck me because both Republicans and Democrats seemed to enjoy it a lot. That’s rare in this redder-than-red town.

You might get even more out of some parts of “That Book Is Dangerous!” than I did because you have kids and I don’t, and so much of it is about the assaults on what they read. There’s a good section on a YA novel called “The Hate U Give,” which might be the most challenged book in America. I knew about all the fights over it but not what was in it until I read Szetela.

“That Book Is Dangerous!” has a good index, so you if you don’t have time to read the whole thing, even though it’s fairly short, you can look up books or authors like, say, “The Hate U Give” or “Dr. Seuss” or “Roald Dahl” and get a good, brief (and sometimes funny or sarcastic) sense of the battles.

Expand full comment
Jamie's avatar

oh interesting, i’ve read the hate u give, though it’s been awhile, i had no idea it was the most challenged book in america!

Expand full comment
Steve Stockdale's avatar

I heard it as "you write to figure out what you think." But not sure where I got it.

Expand full comment
Jan Harayda's avatar

There are a lot of variations on that one, and they're all correct. So you can't go wrong, however you say it.

Expand full comment
Jerry Adler's avatar

Fascinating about Churchill. I thought I coined the aphorism “writing is thinking,” but I guess I must have stolen it from him.

Expand full comment
Jan Harayda's avatar

You're still right, though :).

Expand full comment
Candi Miller's avatar

Such an interesting post, beginning with Don Murray's “Writing problems are thinking problems." I used to tell my students about E.M. Foster's: "How do I know what I think until I see what I say?"

Off to check out Szetela. Thanks for the rec.

Expand full comment
Jan Harayda's avatar

Don loved that Forster quote, too! I first saw it in one of his handouts, and I'm sure he's quoted it in one of his books. Thanks for reading.

Expand full comment